After reviewing surveillance video from the bar, officers learned the fight began as an argument between the victim and Jonathan Soto, 26, of Ashe Place.
Soto, Lesure and Fermin were each charged with second-degree assault, second-degree conspiracy to commit assault, interfering with an officer, and breach of peace.
Castillo was charged with third-degree conspiracy to commit assault and was released on a promise to appear in court on Nov. 3.