Which coffee percolator is best? The robust flavors and rich texture of percolator coffee are hard to mimic with other brewing methods. These vintage tools are largely similar to their original counterparts from the early 1800s and are ideal for bold coffee lovers and coffee connoisseurs. If you’re looking for a high-quality percolator that can brew enough for avid coffee drinkers, the Black and Decker Farberware 12-Cup Percolator is the top choice. What to know before you buy a coffee percolator Though they’re not as popular as they were before the automatic drip coffee machine hit the market, coffee percolators can brew a cup as strong as ever.